AAO-HNSF
  • Register Now
  • Posters
  • Meeting Coverage
  • Annual Meeting Program
  • OTO Experience
  • How to Claim CME
Topics
  • Meeting Coverage
  • Annual Meeting Program
  • OTO Experience
  • How to Claim CME
Resources
  • Register Now
  • Posters
Facebook iconInstagram iconTwitter X icon YouTube icon
Sep 6th, 2022

Debating Uncertainty

The Great Debates series stirs robust discussions.


Dr. Damask headshot
Cecelia Damask, DO

There are two sides in every debate, and that’s exactly what AAO-HNSF’s Annual Meeting will offer during its Great Debates in Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery series. Meeting organizers expect a robust discussion for each of 12 topics presented throughout the Annual Meeting, promising to fire up your imagination and inspire you in your practice of medicine.

Cecelia Damask, DO, educational innovation strategic team leader for the  Annual Meeting Program Committee (AMPC) said the AMPC describes the series as a “collective focus and deliberation with prominent thought leaders.” Now in its second year, the series is designed to identify contentious issues deserving of that collective focus and deliberation, with moderators pushing these discussions forward via structured debate. 

“There are so many wonderful topics being debated at this year's Annual Meeting,” Dr. Damask said. “Physicians in general seek concrete facts and sharply delineated categories, such as positive and negative or true and false. Unfortunately, medicine is more nuance-driven and is ambiguous. Understanding this is particularly important for otolaryngologists because of the complexity of our specialty.”

The large, heterogenous specialty of otolaryngology encompasses many areas and topics that are heavily debated and remain controversial. Although physicians place a high value on certainty, she said, that “the Great Debates allow speakers and attendees to explore the uncertainty that may always exist in medicine.”

For example, Dr Damask said, “Sometimes a direct causality between a treatment and an outcome cannot be proven or the extent of a surgery necessary for a patient to remain disease-free is not known” thus, remaining controversial and up for debate. 

The 12 debates will span an array of interests, from rhinology/allergy and sleep medicine to the business of medicine/practice management and patient safety/quality improvement.

“Some debates are long-standing controversies like radiation versus surgery as a primary cure for a cancer patient,” Dr. Damask said. “With the advent of newer surgical techniques, some debates are around the extent of surgery needed.  Other controversies being explored are changes in healthcare like the increasing role of APPs in otolaryngology or adding other medical specialty providers to an otolaryngology practice or where is the optimal location to perform a surgery.”

The goal of the Great Debates, she said, is to share expert opinions with attendees on topics that don’t have an obvious answer for many of the conundrums in otolaryngology. Attendees will be presented with evidence as well as opinions from both sides of a particular debate and must decide for themselves which approach they will ultimately take in their individual respective practices with their own patients.

“We will continue to face a healthcare environment that is uncertain and continually evolving,” she said. “Hopefully attendees will walk away from the Great Debates inspired to want to stay up-to-date about future advances in our specialty.”

Otology/Neurotology
MÉNIÈRE’S DISEASE: MEDICAL VS. SURGICAL MANAGEMENT

September 11 | 9:15 – 10:15 am (ET)
Moderators: Meredith E. Adams, MD, MS, and Gregory J. Basura, MD, PhD
Debate Speaker #1: Steven D. Rauch, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Jay T. Rubinstein, MD, PhD

Rhinology/Allergy
MAXIMALIST VS. MINIMALIST APPROACH TO SINUS SURGERY: WHAT’S BETTER?

September 11 | 2:15 – 3:15 pm (ET)
Moderator: Sarah K. Wise, MD, MSCR
Debate Speaker #1: Devyani Lal, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Troy D. Woodard, MD

Professional and Personal Development
THE ROLE OF APPS IN YOUR PRACTICE: TEAMMATE OR FREE AGENT?

September 11 |  2:15 – 3:15 pm (ET)
Moderator: Michael J. Brenner, MD |
Debate Speaker #1: Gavin Setzen, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Kristi S. Gidley, PA-C, MSHA
Debate Speaker #3: Elisabeth D.H. Ference, MD, MPH
Debate Speaker #4: Wendy Mackey, APRN-BC, MSN, CORLN

Pediatric Otolaryngology
TO CLIP OR TO NOT CLIP: THAT IS THE TONGUE TIE QUESTION

September 11 | 2:15 – 3:15 pm (ET)
Moderator: Sanjay R. Parikh, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Anna H. Messner, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Nikhila P. Raol, MD, MPH

Business of Medicine/Practice Management
ALLERGY IN OTOLARYNGOLOGY: DIY OR HIRE AN OUTSIDE AGENT?

September 12 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET)
Moderator: Dole Baker, MD, and Cecelia Damask, DO
Debate Speaker #1: Douglas D. Reh, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Gavin Setzen, MD

Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
CONTROVERSIES IN FACIAL REANIMATION

September 12 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET)
Moderators: Teresa M. O, MD, and Linda N. Lee, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Tessa Hadlock, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Kofi Boahene, MD

Patient Safety and Quality Improvement
DOES SURGICAL VOLUME MATTER? A PRO-CON DEBATE

September 12 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET)
Moderator: Sujana S. Chandrasekhar, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Richard W. Waguespack, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Amy Chen, MD, MPH
Debate Speaker #3: Catherine K. Hart, MD
Debate Speaker #4: Soham Roy, MD, MMM

Comprehensive Otolaryngology
WHERE WOULD YOU DO YOUR NEXT SINUS SURGERY: IN-OFFICE VS. SURGERY CENTER

September 12 | 3:45 – 4:45 Pm (ET)
Moderator: William R. Blythe, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Bradford A. Woodworth, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Marc G. Dubin, MD

Head and Neck Surgery
RADIATION VS. ENDOSCOPIC MANAGEMENT OF EARLY GLOTTIC CANCER

September 13 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET)
Moderator: D. Gregory Farwell, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Nancy Lee, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Michael L. Hinni, MD

Endocrine Surgery
RADIO FREQUENCY ABLATION OF THYROID NODULES: IS THYROID SURGERY BECOMING OBSOLETE?

September 13 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET)
Moderator: Joseph Scharpf, MD
Debate Speaker #1: Lisa A. Orloff, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Michael C. Singer, MD

Sleep Medicine |
SHOULD ADENOTONSILLECTOMY BE THE FIRST-LINE TREATMENT FOR ALL PEDIATRIC PATIENTS WITH MILD OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP APNEA?

September 13 | 10:45 – 11:45 am (ET) |
Moderator: Nikhila P. Raol, MD, MPH |
Debate Speaker #1: Derek J. Lam, MD, MPH
Debate Speaker #2: Stacey L. Ishman, MD, MPH

Laryngology/Brocho-Esophagology
KTP ABLATION VS. EN BLOC CO2 RESECTION OF EARLY GLOTTIC CANCER

September 13 | 1:00 – 2:00 pm (ET)
Moderator: Jeanne L. Hatcher, MD
Debate Speaker #1: James A. Burns, MD
Debate Speaker #2: Andrew J. McWhorter, MD

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

More Content
Orestes headshot
AAO-HNSF 2022
Session Features Feedback Fundamentals for Surgical Success
Sep 13th, 2022
Mehta, Langerman, Gibber headshots
Meeting Coverage
Updating Post-Residency Surgical Training for the Modern Era
Sep 13th, 2022
Harrill and Woodard headshots
Meeting Coverage
Meeting the Challenges in Value-Based Healthcare
Sep 13th, 2022
COVID-19 graphic
Meeting Coverage
COVID Implications for Otolaryngology
Sep 13th, 2022
Krishna, Schmalbach, Russell headshots
Meeting Coverage
Surgeons Need to Stay Fit and Active to Stay Injury-Free
Sep 13th, 2022
Crosby, Glazer, Tillman and Kupfer headshots
Meeting Coverage
Removing Obstacles to Gender Bias in Otolaryngology
Sep 13th, 2022
Maturo, Ishman and Schwartz headshots
Meeting Coverage
New Consensus Statement Updates Management of Pediatric OSA after Adenotonsillectomy
Sep 13th, 2022
Raynor and Lee headshots
Meeting Coverage
Harnessing Your Inner Taskmaster
Sep 13th, 2022
Cho and Turner headshots
Meeting Coverage
Don’t Take Your Writing for Granted
Sep 12th, 2022
Posters General 615b589360ac0
Meeting Coverage
2022 Scientific Poster Winners
Sep 12th, 2022
Getty Images 1335023433
Meeting Coverage
2022 OTO Experience Booth Winners
Sep 12th, 2022
(From Left) Patti J. Ayars, Dana M. Thompson, MD, MS, MBA, Rahul Shah, MD, MBA, Carole R. Bradford, MD, MS, and Claire M. Lawlor, MD.
Meeting Coverage
Getting the Encouragement You Need to Advance Your Career
Sep 12th, 2022
AAO-HNSF
Facebook iconInstagram iconTwitter X icon YouTube icon
© 2025 Ascend Media. All rights reserved.